Monday, February 16, 2015

Police Court 1960



A typical morning in police court.


The Municipal Act required cities and towns to accommodate a police court. Sylvannus Weegar may have been North Bay's initial police magistrate in 1909. Prior to this time, the stipendiary magistrate presided over minor criminal offences. The provincial government appointed the police magistrate and the local municipality received a good portion of the fines after deducting a portion for the magistrate's salary. Up to 1968 when the province assumed responsibility for the administration of justice, police court convened in municipal premises and for the majority of time that meant the town hall.

The most regularly reported business in the local newspaper over time has been an almost daily summary of magistrate's court. It is beyond the purpose of this piece to tell that story and the job of reanimating the past in descriptive detail is left to future reporters. What I propose to share with the reader is a brief pen sketch of the police court landscape in 1960. It's more a vignette than a chronicle.

The setting is a typical Monday morning court hearing. The courtroom is located at the city hall above the police station on McIntyre Street at Ferguson. It is a scene reminiscent of past police court sessions.

The chairs in the council chamber are about two thirds occupied when Richard Francis Donnelly Q.C. enters the courtroom from his law office across the street just before court is ready to open. He made a habit of punctuality. He walks directly to his place at the counsel table without fanfare or socializing. He may speak briefly with the Crown or a police witness but was anxious to get on with his long list of cases. Some of his clients are in custody while others wait their turn in the chamber. He has no briefcase and only a few pieces of paper that he lays on the table. He takes his seat and looks towards the dais as he awaits the imminent arrival of the magistrate. He is mentally reviewing his argument relying on his rich memory and ability to choreograph facts. He appears undisturbed. The truth is that his stomach is likely in turmoil and his mind is burdened with the details of his cases. A situation we know as information overload. The unobserved stress of practice and the daily pressure of representing numerous customers will have a detrimental affect on his health in his lifetime. To-day he appears unaffected.

He earlier finished interviewing some last minute clients in his office and dispatched them to take their seats in the courtroom. He is used to walking to the courtroom himself and declines to accompany clients into the building. He’s short and spare in stature in his early years. Donnelly has been a lawyer since 1950. His uncle's illness brought him to North Bay to mind his uncle’s practice until he recovered from serious illness. Sadly, his popular uncle died 3 months later. Donnelly considered leaving since he preferred to return to his southwestern Ontario roots. That failed to develop and he ended up spending his entire career in North Bay.

By 1960, Donnelly held a reputation as a competent and successful defence counsel. He was particularly effective on his feet. He prepared properly, thought quickly and brought a remarkable insight in the human condition to his work. The tools of his trade included an almost natural persuasive power, excellent negotiation skills and capacity if not to turn the facts in his favour then to minimize their impact. By neutralizing the severity of the charges, he raised a reasonable doubt. That is the ultimate goal of a successful defence counsel. Many of his clients walked away without penalty or settled for a plea of guilt to a lesser charge. There was no dispute about his talent at cross examination. Few lawyers matched his capacity and organizational talent to exam witnesses.

Maitland Gould took his place at the appointed time. He was direct and clearly at ease in his role. A magistrate since 1943, Maitland grew up in North Bay where his father, Melrose Gould, practised law as one of the pioneer lawyers in town. In 1916, Melrose move his family and practice to Bowmanville. When Maitland finished law school, he returned to North Bay to practice with John H. McDonald, Melrose’s former junior partner and by this time a seasoned politician, experienced lawyer and soon to be judge. Maitland, known to friends as Kelly, performed his magisterial role with dignity and reserve. His reputation was unblemished and he was respected for his honesty, mental capacity and fairness. At times he had to be firm, yet even then he displayed courtesy and the public approved of the manner in which he ran his court. His judicial chair sat on a raised platform that backed on the Ferguson Street side of the chamber in those days. That was the arrangement for council meetings before it moved to the other end of the chamber. That later arrangement placed the dais at the other end of the council chamber and up against the wall that touched Cochrane block.

Edwin Alcott Tilley Q.C. was at ease as he sat at the counsel table waiting for court to commence. He was only the 3rd Crown attorney for the Judicial District of Nipissing and approaching his 25th anniversary in that post. While still displaying energy, he was winding down a disciplined career as the people’s representative in the courts. Mr. Tilley was dignified in conduct and appearance. A conspicuous habit was his daily visit to the Chicago Restaurant. He was a familiar sight on Main Street as he ventured to the Chicago to sip his coffee and visit with his good friend Mr. Sing, restaurant proprietor. They were often joined by town solicitor Harry Reynolds Q.C. in the days before his appointment to the bench in Sault Ste Marie.

Mr. Tilley was average height (about 5’ 7”), dressed in a 3 piece suit and wore a fedora. If he had a distinguishing feature it was his mini cigar. He smoked lightly on the ever present stubby and slightly twisted cigar. While the name escapes me, it was close to what we might call a cigarillo today. A quiet man, he avoided drama yet prepared his briefs with care and made a good account of himself. He was no pushover.

Donnelly always called this place "police court" even long after the name changed to magistrate’s court. The police court was Donnelly’s sand box. Mostly through reputation, many accused hired him and sought his assistance. This included police officers who he might have raked over the coals on the witness stand and later hired him to undertake their civil work. Donnelly had many of the leading citizens in town as clients. At the same time, he represented the ruffians, hoodlums and thieves yet preferred to call them customers. When George Wallace wasn’t in court, Donnelly had seniority and his matters proceeding ahead of others.

A stranger attending the 2nd floor courtroom session at the town hall would observe Magistrate Gould on the bench, a number of police witnesses, a council chamber nearly full and some lawyers seated at the counsel table. As proceedings commenced, Mr. Tilley reached into his suit pocket to extract the several informations for the day's sittings. This practice was a holdover from earlier times. It was now a function of court administration that Mr. Tilley found difficult to accept. When he sorted through to find the information he wanted to open the session, he read the name and handed it to the clerk.

On the other side, a young looking lawyer rose in response when the accused was named. Before long the trial was underway and the fencing commenced. Donnelly exhibited a measured and deferential posture to the court. He did his job undramatically and went through the process paying particular attention to the evidence. He was blessed with a magnificent memory that was no doubt fine tuned with abundant practice. His strategy was to wage a standard approach and wait for an opportunity to gain strength from an inconsistency in the evidence. In other words, let's spar for a while until I get a sense of your accuracy, honesty and purpose. After a series of simple questions, the nervous police officer might contradict himself and leave an opening for further investigation. Donnelly made certain he knew the facts before court. Once a witness started to fumble, Donnelly's questioning became more direct and unsettling. Without being offensive, he could confuse a witness sufficiently to render the evidence suspect and unreliable. In his submission to the court, he used the conflicting evidence to cast doubt on the charges. Frequently, his gift of language and persuasion led him to argue that his client was a saint and the charges were all a big mistake and should be dismissed. In reality, the thug he represented and appearing in an ill-fitting suit was the real villain. Invariably, he would be the protagonist legitimately charged with a major assault after he pummelled an opponent outside a beverage room or in the weekly Saturday after midnight street fight that took place outside the Torbay restaurant. When the three policemen who responded to the brouhaha took their turn giving evidence, he cross-examined each to the point that there was inconsistency in their testimony and some uncertainty that the event ever occurred.

To the casual observer this was a surprising turn of events to point of bordering on entertainment. He was capable of making light at the appropriate time but only if it advanced the interests of his client. When he was in full flight, the young lawyers in the courtroom sat in amazement and followed his every word for their own edification and so they could share the sometimes unbelievable results with their legal colleagues.

Looking to the back of the large council chamber, one could see the figure of Tom Frair, town clerk, leaning against the door frame of his office, smoking a cigarette, quietly observing and enjoying Donnelly perform his magic.

That was a typical morning in police court.

No comments: