Nipissing Judicial Appointment.
There is scarcely a governmental executive decision that quenches the thirsty appetite for prestige, creates more anticipation and brings greater disappointment for party faithful than an appointment to the bench.
It is a process whose inner workings are largely foreign to the average citizen apart from occasional mild speculation. The arcane selection process is staged while politicians hatch new judges in an aura of a papal enclave where the victor is undetermined until the smoke appears.
But make no mistake about the process. The real fury occurs outside public view where MPs struggle to make deals, hound ministers and call in their markers to advance the ambitious hopes and certain promises made to eager candidates and their supporters to produce a winner.
There are innumerable factors that come into play in the judicial appointment process. When Ontario had two levels of s 96 judges, the executive leaned towards rewarding unspectacular party stalwarts with appointments to the county and district courts and preferred to select counsel with name recognition and demonstrated experience and more potential to the High Court. Apart from the occasional disappointment, both major political parties followed this model. While the High Court judges may have received the loftier prize, the community face of the judicial system was largely reflective of the judicial duties assigned to the local judge in the county town.
By 1934, Nipissing District Court Judges Joseph Alphonse Valin (1895) and Harry Darling Leask (1903) had put in over 30 years each and were ready to step into retirement. While both were eligible, the spotlight was on resilient veteran senior judge Valin who announced his exit in 1932 yet agreed to stay on pending appointment of a replacement. While there was no shortage of candidates ready to replace Leask, his position would remain unfilled on his departure on two counts. First, Nipissing no longer qualified for a junior judge and second, there was a deliberate effort by government to reduce the number of judges in Ontario.
Given the small number of Ontario bilingual judges, there was a quiet expectation that Valin would be succeeded by a French-Canadian judge in a district with a substantial French-Canadian population. But the hunger for power left the race wide open and failed to deter the ambitions of individuals and groups who felt they stood a good chance to influence the final outcome.
For Premier Bennett, this generated a steady stream of mail and representations from supplicants and supporters that had to be managed in the agenda of an already beleaguered leader saddled with overcoming insurmountable difficulties brought on by a national depression.
French-Canadians Isolated.
The Anglo-Saxon Protestant majority maintained a stranglehold in Ontario and strong groups within this mainstream were determined to keep it that way. It is a matter of historical record that French-Canadian efforts to penetrate Ontario society were thwarted by stiff resistence from the ruling elite. One can point to the Manitoba Schools Question, Ontario Regulation 17, and internal religious and cultural turbulence between Irish and French Catholics as strong examples of the turmoil faced by the French-Canadian minority. The continuing campaign to isolate francophones was evident in their under-representation in Ontario institutions. Of particular concern was their exclusion from meaningful respresentation in government positions and the judiciary.

No comments:
Post a Comment