Wednesday, January 16, 2019




Our Home on 

Native Land 



  
The Robinson-Huron Treaty (1850) that conveyed certain lands to the Crown opened up a vast sweep of untamed territory north of the French River and Lake Huron.  Once Indian land claims were concluded and reservations allocated, the Province of Canada set about to prepare a large portion of its domain for colonization. By establishing Indian reservations, the Treaty demarked Crown land available for settlers and entrepreneurs to set up shops, invest in mining and logging enterprises, and hold title to property. To prepare for colonists, the planners laid the foundation for public order by enacting legislation for the “better administration of justice in unorganized tracts”[1]. The goal was to transform the wilds from their primitive state to a region that would attract settlers to harvest the resources of a plentiful land.

John A. Macdonald reasoned that frontier settlement at an incipient stage needed an underpinning of regulatory guidelines in statutory form.  An interesting feature of his governance model is that he adopted freshly crafted legislation applicable only to the districts rather than extend existing practices from old Ontario to the new territory. He viewed the maturation of the frontier as a work in progress.  It was a broad process of determining what this part of the country should become and how best to achieve that goal. As attorney general, he pressed for passage of legislation to shape the Temporary Judicial Districts of Nipissing[2]and Algoma.[3]The enabling legislation that spelled out the particulars and set ground rules for the newborn territory received approval in 1857.[4] For the new Nipissing district, the legislative language outlined steps for forming township councils, appointment of administrative and judicial officials and the associated provision of court services.  

Pre-Confederation

Prior to Confederation, the governor determined the shape of political and judicial administration.   A proclamation was issued to divide Upper Canada into four districts.[5]  In 1792, Governor Simcoe further divided these districts into nineteen original counties.[6]The governor appointed officials on the English model and replicated in the colonies. Magistrates sitting in quarter sessions of the peace administered authority in these districts.[7]These courts had power over public works including the erection of court houses and jails, “highways, assessment, appointment of district and township constables, pound keepers”[8]and typical responsibilities that fall under local control. This regulatory regime prevailed until 1841 when these functions devolved to municipal councils. 

These were turbulent political times as the Province of Canada struggled with calls for responsible government and representation by population.  In the years leading to Confederation, political alliances were tenuous and shifting allegiances resulted in governments that were short lived. 

The period did produce a government structure that favoured two levels of administration based on the county model introduced by the Baldwin Act. 

District governance.

The northern lands above the counties provided a challenge for Macdonald.  What governance model would meet the primitive conditions of a territory that extended from the French River to the north-western boundaries of the Province?  County government was out of the question since there was nothing to administer.  The district was a geographical wilderness.  The land remained in the state of nature.  

In considering the deliberations to select a governance model, Macdonald saw the need for a centralized administration akin to a nanny state.  He harkened back to the earlier period controlled by justices of the peace as a structural model to suit a developing state. It had appealing elements and he liked the idea of a unitary system featuring central control and governance by magistrates. 

Macdonald recognized that his main task was to establish the rule of law in the “unorganized tracts of country within the limits of Upper Canada”.  He chose to fashion a framework for government to suit a hinterland, accommodate expected growth and yet permit flexibility in a transitional stage. The district needed a design during in its formative period to steer the territory in its passage from conception to reality. At this point, the district was an expression of a land preparing for intending settlers who required a structure to keep the peace and to enforce and prosecute the law.[9] It was a region in limbo and for the foreseeable future had to function as a ward of the Crown. In selecting rules for governance, Macdonald concluded that districts would be best served by a mixed blend of judicial and administrative control.

The easy part was the court system. He adopted a lower court structure modelled on the Division Court in the counties.  It was sufficient to deal with petty crimes and resolve personal and commercial disputes between parties.  The higher end civil and criminal matters would still have to be dealt with in nearby counties. For Nipissing, that meant County Court in Pembroke.

Macdonald made provision for local government. Where population warranted, voters in surveyed townships could petition to establish a council headed by an elected reeve and four councillors.     
   
In unorganized tracts, the Lieutenant Governor appointed a stipendiary magistrate to serve a period of colonization. He held the local reins of power and exercised “magisterial, judicial and other functions” as authorized by legislation. It served to get the territorial outpost up and running with legal machinery to control criminal activity and provide a forum to settle civil disputes.  The Stipendiary Magistrate became the point man with sufficient powers to act as a quasi warden and enforce the laws.

               He occupied a key position, had authority to manage the affairs for a district and wore two important hats – one judicial and the other administrative.  It was a throwback to earlier times when justices of the peace had both judicial and executive power.  

In northern districts, there was no upper tier governmental structure found in the counties of old Ontario.  Unlike southern county units, districts were widespread, sparsely populated, undeveloped and unsuitable for the county structure of governance.  The emergent district was in its infancy and unable to provide services offered in counties.  It was up to the province to fund infrastructure and essential services beyond the capacity of township councils and school boards.


Enabling legislation [assented 10June 1857]


An Act to provide for the better administration of Justice in the unorganized tracts of Country within the limits of this Province


The Assembly passed legislation to form temporary judicial districts in unorganized tracts bordering on Lakes Superior and Huron and “other parts of Canada not included within the settle limits of any County or District.”  The district was to be divided into “two or more divisions” for administrative and court services.   This scheme established Division Courts throughout the district where population warranted. That system remained in place for more than a century. It brought the inferior courts to local communities. Division Court is now known as Small Claims Court.  The fundamental procedure in these courts remains unchanged.  The first sittings of Division Court in Nipissing took place in Mattawa.  

Nipissing Stipendiary Magistrates.

The “Temporary Judicial District of Nipissing” was established by An Act to provide for the better administration of Justice in the unorganized tracts of County within the limits of this Province[11]assented to 10 June 1857 and officially proclaimed 12 April 1858.The legislation clothed the Nipissingstipendiary magistratewith considerable authority and responsibility. He was paid an annual salary yet was entitled to fees when acting as a justice of the peace.  He had extensive administrative functions such as appointing constables, acting as land registrar, serving as coroner and other dutues.   As Division Court Judge of the district, he presided over civil and routine criminal matters. He had similar jurisdiction and powers in Division Court as County Court Judges. 

John A. Macdonald appointed Thomas Hall Johnson as stipendiary magistrate for Nipissing with residence in Pembroke. Johnson had served in the legislature with Macdonald and had ample lawmaking experience.  He held the position of County Treasurer of the District of Ottawa in 1839 when L’Orignal was the county town.[12]His public service career included two terms as legislative member for Prescott and Russell, deputy clerk of the Crown and a brief stint as postmaster[13].  Johnson held several government positions in Nipissing including issuer of licences for tavern and shopkeepers.  In 1868-69, there were five tavern licences issued in Nipissing with a fee of $13.75.  In Mattawa, John Bangs and Noah Timmins held shop licences for a fee of $8.75.[14] Bangs was an agent for Hudson Bay Company while Timmins was listed as a farmer, trader and hotel keeper. Johnson continued as Nipissing stipendiary magistrate until August 1869 when he accepted the prestigious posting as assistant Commissioner of Crown Lands.

John Doran of Perth succeeded Johnson as stipendiary magistrate and registrar with residence in Pembroke. His appointment coincided with Johnson’s resignation although he likely began his assignment a year later, in August 1870, when he received his first salary payment.  Prior to his appointment, Doran played a leading role in matters of public interest. He was justice of peace for many years. In politics he was a Reformer and unsuccessful candidate in 1857. He accepted the stipendiary magistrate position at age forty-four following praiseworthy public service as reeve, councillor and warden of the united counties of Lanark and Renfrew[15].  In Pembroke, Doran easily established himself as a devoted Roman Catholic who steered the construction of the church and joined with Thomas Murray to own considerable real estate in the town.  He held court in Pembroke and travelled by canoe, led by robust Indian paddlers, as required to Mattawa, the early district court location. John Doran had health issues and sought relief from the warmer climate in Denver Colorado.[16] When he failed to regain his vigour, Doran resigned.
Mowat established a second stipendiary magistrate position by appointing Edward Barnes Borron for Northern Nipissing in the former Hudson’s Bay territory. His task was more to scout out the far north than dispense justice. He made periodic visits to his region in the short time he remained in this position.  As a non-resident engineer and surveyor, his assignment consisted mostly of exploration during a period that a boundary dispute existed between Ontario and Manitoba. In 1886 Borron issued his Report on that part of the Basin of Hudson’s Bay belonging to the Province of Ontariooutlining the findings of his explorations.  He describes in some detail his arduous canoe route to reach his destination with the help of Indian guides and support from Hudson Bay Company officers.  The description of the land, timber and mineral resources provides an early record of the vast territory he covered. His duties as stipendiary magistrate rank secondary to his desire to familiarize others with the wilderness in his control.  His concern for the welfare of the Indian people persuaded him to delve into their social conditions, lifestyle and daily needs.  While conceding that wrong doers must be punished, Borron believed the aims of justice were best achieved by promoting good behaviour and discouraging unlawful acts. 

In February 1885, the Mowat government appointed William Doran a former saw mill operator in Sharbot Lake. William succeeded his brother John as stipendiary magistrate and land registrar. For four years prior to his appointment, Doran served as chief clerk in the Bureau of Industries, Agricultural Department in Toronto.[17]Previous to his work in Toronto, William was a leading Reform supporter and unsuccessful candidate in Perth. He added the duties of coroner for District of Nipissing in April 1886.[18]He was the first stipendiary magistrate to live in Nipissing with a home in North Bay.[19] 

John Loughrin succeeded William Doran as Nipissing stipendiary magistrate in June 1902 at a salary of $1,600.[20] The former MLA inherited land registration functions asMaster of Titles and Registrar of Deeds for Nipissing.[21]Loughrin was born in Renfrew County in 1853. Following school in Pembroke, he worked as a clerk for Murray Brothers’ stores in Beachburg and Renfrew.  In 1876 he arrived in Mattawa where he joined Timmins and Gorman until 1879.  In that year, he returned to T. & W. Murray at their business in Deux Rivieres until the store moved to Mattawa when it became Messrs. Murrray’s & Loughrin. His public service began in 1886 as reeve in Mattawa for two years.  He was also a separate school trustee. When Nipissing became an electoral district in 1890, Loughrin was selected Reform candidate and defeated Liberal-Conservative David Purvis of North Bay.  In 1894 he was re-elected over Independent Conservative Steven Fournier of Sudbury and in his last electoral campaign in 1898 defeated Charles Lamarche.  In 1893 he ended partnership with T. & W. Murray and in 1894 purchased the Mattawa hardware business of Messrs. Dunlop & Co.[22]

In 1905, the Whitney government dismissed John Loughrin for partisan political activity while serving as a public officer.  The Conservatives elected Charles Lamarche in East Nipissing who gave up his seat so that Frank Cochrane could contest the vacancy. Cochrane was acclaimed and immediately entered Whitney’s cabinet.  Loughrin’s dismissal opened the door for Whitney to reward Lamarche. That occurred in October 1905, when Whitney appointed Lamarche police magistrate and registrar of deeds for the District of Nipissing.  With the appointment of Harry Darling Leask as junior judge for Nipissing, there was no further need for a stipendiary magistrate to assist Judge Valin with Division Court hearings.  A police magistrate assumed judicial oversight for offenses previously administered by the stipendiary magistrate.  For these minor offences, the mayor or reeve had magisterial authority to conduct hearings and make findings of guilt or innocence.
            
             


[1]20 Victoria, chapter 60.
[2]officially proclaimed 12 April 1858.  
[3]The move to establish Algoma and Nipissing recognized a need to establish control over a vast unorganized tract in preparation for settlement. 
[4]An Act to provide for the better administration of Justice in the unorganized tracts of the Country within the limits of this Province [Statutes of Canada 1857; 20 Victoria, chapter 60; assented to 10 June 1857]
[5]The Ontario Historical Society 1967, Profiles of a Province, 34.
[6]Ibid.,35.
[7]Ibid.
[8]Ibid.
[9]See: An act for the prevention and repression of outrages in violation of the peace on the frontier of this Province, and for other purposes- 28 Vic, chapter 1 assented to 6February 1865.

[10]Surtees, R.J. Indian Land Surrenders in Ontario 1763-1867. Ottawa: Department of Indian and Northern Affairs, 1984. (not posted).

[11]Statutes of Canada 1857; 20 Victoria, chapter 60; 
[12]Appendix to Journal of the House of Asembly of Unpper Canada, Vol 1, Part 2. Treasurer’s Returns, 5thSession 13thParliament, 3rdVictoria 1840, 539.
[13]Lovell’s Directory for Canada, 1851.
[14]Ontario Sessional Papers, 32 Victoria, 1868-69, 31.
[15]Perth Courier, 14 October 1870.
[16]Ibid, 19 October 1883.
[17]Cochrane, William, The Canadian Album: Men of Canada; Or, Success by Example, 1893, 350.
[18]Dominion Annual Register and Review1886, 146.
[19]Perth Courier, 27 February 1885
[20]Toronto Daily Star,7 June 1902, 5.
[21]Ibid.
[22]Mattawa Tribune, Christmas edition, 1895.

No comments: